REVISED
SOLICITATION PRIVILEGES UPON CONSOLIDATION OF
CME AND CBOT TRADING FLOORS
This Special Executive Report addresses the
cross-exchange solicitation privileges which will be applicable to CME and CBOT members upon
consolidation of the CME and CBOT trading floors and supersedes S-4630 issued on October 25,
2007. The revised policy extends cross-exchange solicitation privileges in CBOT agricultural
futures and options and CME commodity futures and options to individuals holding CBOT Series B-1
(Full) memberships and CME memberships, as described in this document.
Presently, CME, IMM and IOM members on the CME
trading floors have solicitation privileges in all CME products, and CBOT members on the CBOT
trading floors have solicitation privileges only in those CBOT products assigned to their specific
membership Series. In general, these policies will be maintained on the consolidated
floor. However, in order to minimize disruptions to current CME and CBOT members’ business
activities, floor markets and seat markets, current members will be allowed certain cross-exchange
solicitation privileges in specified products of both exchanges on the consolidated trading
floor.
Solicitation Defined
For the purposes of this policy, solicitation
shall include any of the following:
1) Being compensated for the production of
orders;
2) Providing personal opinions regarding trading
strategies or market direction for the purpose of generating interest in exchange products;
3) Exercising discretion with respect to any
order.
Clerical activities, including the entry of
non-discretionary orders and the communication of market information, shall not be considered
solicitation.
Cross-Exchange Solicitation Privileges to be
Grandfathered as of October 25, 2007
Certain cross-exchange solicitation privileges
will be provided to Series B-1 (Full), Series B-2 (Associate), Series B-5 (COM), CME, IMM and IOM
memberships that were owned or leased as of the close of business on October 25, 2007 (hereinafter
referred to as “COB October 25”).
Member firms
will be allowed to maintain grandfathered
cross-exchange solicitation privileges with respect to the portfolio of memberships owned or leased
by the firm as of COB October 25. The grandfathered privileges will belong to the member firm
owning or leasing the membership rather than to the individual on the membership, thereby allowing
member firms to determine how best to utilize their floor staffs. Memberships purchased after
COB October 25 will not have cross-exchange solicitation privileges. A member firm that
terminates the lease of a membership or has its lease terminated will lose the grandfathered
solicitation privileges associated with that lease unless it obtains a new lease in the same
membership Series or Division within 30 days.
Each individual member
who owns a membership as of COB October 25 will
maintain grandfathered solicitation privileges with respect to that membership. An owner who
sells a membership after COB October 25 will not be afforded grandfathered solicitation privileges
with respect to any new membership purchase, and the cross-exchange solicitation privileges cannot
be transferred to the new owner of the membership. An individual lessee will maintain
grandfathered solicitation privileges provided that the lease is paid for by the individual
member. If the lease is being paid for by a member firm, the member firm will retain the
grandfathered privileges associated with the leased membership. An individual lessee who
relinquishes a current membership lease or has his lease terminated will retain grandfathered
solicitation privileges only if he obtains a new lease in the same Series or Division within 30
days.
Member firms will shortly be provided with a list
of all memberships which exchange records reflect as having been owned by or assigned to the member
firm as of COB October 25. Member firms will be required to submit a form to the Shareholder
Relations and Membership Services Department identifying any memberships that were being leased by
the member firm as of COB October 25. Additional information concerning submission of the form
will be provided in the cover letter which will accompany the list of memberships owned or assigned
to the member firm.
Grandfathered Cross-Exchange Floor Solicitation
Privileges
Subject to the grandfathering provisions described
above, the following cross-exchange solicitation privileges will apply upon consolidation of the
CME and CBOT trading floors:
- CME Division members will have solicitation privileges in all CBOT
futures and options.
- IMM and IOM members will have solicitation privileges in all CBOT
non-agricultural futures and options.
- CME GEM members and CME Agricultural Solicitation Permit holders will
not have any cross-exchange solicitation privileges.
- CBOT Series B-1 (Full) members will have solicitation privileges in
all CME futures and options.
- Series B-2 (Associate) members will have solicitation privileges in
all CME non-commodity futures and options.
- CBOT Series B-5 (COM) members will have solicitation privileges in
all CME non-commodity options.
- CBOT Series B-3 (GIM) and Series B-4 (IDEM) members will not have any
cross-exchange solicitation privileges.
A Frequently Asked Questions document begins on
page 3 of this Notice which provides additional information on the new cross-exchange solicitation
privileges.
Questions regarding the solicitation policy should
be directed to one of the following individuals:
John Curran, Managing Director, Products and
Services, at 312.930.4557
Robert Krewer, Associate Director, Memberships, at
312.930.3483
Robert Sniegowski, Associate Director, Market
Regulation, at 312.648.5493
FAQ Regarding Solicitation Privileges on
the
Consolidated CME and CBOT Trading Floors
Issued Date: January 30, 2008
- How is “solicitation” defined in the context of CME and CBOT
rules?
Solicitation shall include any of the
following:
1) Being compensated for the production of
orders;
2) Providing personal opinions regarding trading
strategies or market direction for the purpose of generating interest in exchange
products;
3) Exercising discretion with respect to any
order.
Clerical activities, including the entry of
non-discretionary orders and the communication of market information, shall not be considered
solicitation.
- If I am not on a membership with grandfathered cross-exchange
solicitation privileges, what products will I be able to solicit on the combined trading
floor?
|
|
CBOT Products
|
|
CME Products
|
|
|
|
Agricultural Products
|
Financials
|
Index, Debt and Energy
|
Metals
|
|
Commodities
|
Interest Rates
|
FX
|
Equities
|
|
|
CBOT Full
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CBOT AM
|
Opts only
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CBOT COM
|
Opts only
|
Opts only
|
Opts only
|
Opts only
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CBOT GIM
|
|
Futs only
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CBOT IDEM
|
|
|
Futs only
|
Futs only
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CME CME
|
|
|
|
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
CME IMM
|
|
|
|
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
CME IOM
|
|
|
|
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
CME GEM
|
|
|
|
|
|
GEM Accessible Products only
|
|
- If I am on a membership with grandfathered cross-exchange
solicitation privileges, what products will I be able to solicit on the combined trading
floor?
|
|
CBOT Products
|
|
CME Products
|
|
|
|
Agricultural
Products
|
Financials
|
Index, Debt and Energy
|
Metals
|
|
Commodities
|
Interest Rates
|
FX
|
Equities
|
|
|
CBOT Full
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
CBOT AM
|
Opts only
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
CBOT COM
|
Opts only
|
Opts only
|
Opts only
|
Opts only
|
|
|
Opts only
|
Opts only
|
Opts only
|
|
|
CBOT GIM
|
|
Futs only
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CBOT IDEM
|
|
|
Futs only
|
Futs only
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CME CME
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
CME IMM
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
CME IOM
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
X
|
|
|
CME GEM
|
|
|
|
|
|
GEM Accessible Products only
|
|
- If I am a CME member with grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation
privileges currently soliciting business from the CME trading floor, how will my cross-exchange
solicitation privileges differ on the combined trading floor?
With respect to solicitation of CME products,
there will be no differences. However, if in addition to CME products you currently solicit in
CBOT products from the CME trading floor, your cross-exchange solicitation privileges will differ
slightly on the combined trading floor. Specifically, IMM and IOM members will have the right
to solicit all products, except CBOT agricultural futures and options, from the combined trading
floor. CME Division members will have the right to solicit all CBOT products, including CBOT
agricultural futures and options, from the combined trading floor.
- If I am a CBOT member with grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation
privileges currently soliciting business from the CBOT trading floor, how will my cross-exchange
solicitation privileges differ on the combined trading floor?
With respect to solicitation of CBOT products,
there will be no differences. However, if in addition to CBOT products you currently solicit
in CME products from the CBOT trading floor, your cross-exchange solicitation privileges will
differ slightly on the combined trading floor. Specifically, Associate (“AM”) members
will have the right to solicit all products, except CME commodity futures and options, from the
combined trading floor. CBOT COM members will have solicitation privileges in all CME options
products except for commodity options. CBOT Full members will have the right to solicit all CME
products, including CME commodity futures and options, from the combined trading floor.
- How long will grandfathered cross-exchange floor solicitation
privileges last?
Generally speaking - as long as the individual or
member firm with the privileges retain their current membership status.
Individual members owning a membership as of the
close of business on October 25, 2007 (hereinafter referred to as “COB October 25”), will maintain
the grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges at all times during which they hold such
membership.
Individual members leasing a membership as of COB
October 25 will maintain the grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges as long as they
are financially responsible for the lease payments and continue to lease their current
membership. If they lose or terminate their current lease, they will have 30 days to secure a
new lease
in the same membership category
to maintain grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges on the combined trading
floor.
Member firms will retain grandfathered
cross-exchange solicitation privileges for each membership owned or leased by the member firm as of
COB October 25 provided that the member firm maintains ownership of, or pays the lease associated
with, such memberships.
- If an individual or member firm purchases a membership after COB
October 25, will the membership have grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges on the
combined trading floor?
No.
- As a
lessor, if I lease my membership to a different trader, will the new lessee have
grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges?
The new lessee will have grandfathered
cross-exchange solicitation privileges only if the new lessee (individual or member firm employee)
previously had grandfathered privileges with respect to a leased membership in the same membership
category within the previous 30 days.
- As an owner of a membership as of COB October 25, will I lose
grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges if my membership is being leased as of that
date or if I lease my membership after that date?
No. The owner of a membership as of COB
October 25 will retain the grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges associated with
that membership for as long as he owns the membership. An owner will permanently lose such
privileges only if the membership is sold.
- May members or member firms sell a membership, buy another membership
and still maintain grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges?
No. Once a membership is sold, the
grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges with respect to that membership will
expire.
- If I am an individual member who owns two memberships, may I sell one
membership and maintain the grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges with respect to
the membership I retain?
Yes, provided that you were the owner of record as
of COB October 25 on the membership you retain.
- If I am
leasing a membership and have grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation
privileges, may I switch leases and maintain my grandfathered privileges?
Yes, as long as you lease a membership in the same
membership category within 30 days of the date you ceased leasing your current membership.
- If I am
leasing a membership, do I have to register my lease in order to maintain my
grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges?
Member firms
that were leasing memberships as of COB October 25
will be required to
register those leases with the Shareholder and Membership Services Department on a
designated form (See Question 20).
An
individual lessee who was leasing a membership as of COB October 25 is
not required to register this lease, provided the lessee continues to hold such
lease.
14. If I switch leases after October 25, 2007 and
lease a membership in the same membership category pursuant to question 12 above, do I have to
register my new lease in order to maintain my grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation
privileges?
Yes. In order to maintain such privileges
with respect to the new lease you must notify the Shareholder Relations and Membership Services
Department at the time you obtain the new lease.
15. If I am
leasing a membership and have grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation
privileges, may I buy a membership and maintain grandfathered privileges?
No. Membership purchases after COB October 25
will not entitle the owner to grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges. A lessee
may only maintain grandfathered privileges after a lease is terminated if the individual leases
another membership in the same membership category within 30 days of relinquishing the previous
lease.
16. For the
purposes of the grandfathering provisions, what organizations are considered to be
member firms?
For the purposes of this policy, a member firm is
considered to be any formally organized membership entity allowed to engage in solicitation
activities on the CME or CBOT trading floor. Membership entities that are registered in a
member firm category that does not permit solicitation privileges on the trading floor will not be
entitled to cross-exchange solicitation privileges on the combined trading floor.
17. Are
registered CME or CBOT broker associations considered member firms for the
purposes of this policy?
No.
18. If a
member firm owns a membership used by a firm employee and the firm employee is not
currently working on the trading floor, will that membership qualify as one of the firm’s
memberships eligible for grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges on the combined
trading floor?
Yes. The grandfathered cross-exchange
solicitation privileges for member firms accrue to all memberships owned or leased by the firm as
of COB October 25 regardless of whether such memberships are currently being used by the member
firm for solicitation purposes on the trading floor. Member firms may transfer these
memberships among firm employees without altering the grandfathered solicitation privileges
attendant to the memberships. A firm will lose grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation
privileges with respect to a membership owned as of COB October 25 if it sells the
membership. Similarly, a member firm will lose grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation
privileges with respect to memberships being leased by the firm if it terminates the lease or has
its lease terminated, unless the firm obtains a new lease in the same membership category within 30
days and provides notice of the new lease to the Shareholder Relations and Membership Services
Department at the time the new lease is obtained.
19. Are
memberships assigned to a member firm eligible for grandfathered cross-exchange
solicitation privileges?
At CME, grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation
privileges will not accrue to member firms with respect to independent membership
assignments. These memberships must be held by the owner of the membership and therefore the
grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges will accrue to the owner of the
membership.
At CME and CBOT, grandfathered cross-exchange
solicitation privileges will remain with a member firm for those membership assignments where the
owner of the membership maintains an acceptable proprietary interest in the member firm pursuant to
the existing policies at each exchange. If the assignment is terminated, the owner of the
membership will retain the grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges.
20. How does
a
member firm register the memberships leased by the firm in order to maintain
grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges with respect to those memberships?
In the near future, member firms eligible for
grandfathered cross-exchange solicitation privileges will be provided a list of all memberships
which exchange records reflected as having been owned by or assigned to the firm (excluding CME
independent membership assignments) as of COB October 25. The list will be accompanied by a
form which member firms will need to complete and return to the Shareholder Relations and
Membership Services Department identifying any memberships being leased by the firm as of October
25, 2007. As noted earlier in this document, additional information concerning
submission of the form will be provided in the cover letter which will accompany the list of
memberships owned or assigned to the member firm.
21. Who should I contact if I have questions
regarding cross-exchange solicitation privileges on the combined CME and CBOT
trading floors?
John Curran, Managing Director, Products and
Services, at 312.930.4557 or
Robert Krewer, Associate Director, Memberships, at
312.930.3483 or
Robert Sniegowski, Associate Director, Market
Regulation, at 312.648.5493 or
|